Tyler Durden in an orange robe


18 August, 2007 by rhesus12

Found a brilliant essay by Dzintars Dzilna on Fight Club as a Zen parable. There’s a lot that’s very good in that movie. I take the fighting itself as a metaphor for having a method or practice, especially one that requires surrender to all the possibilities of reality. Easy to suspect though that there’s some sort of empty hipster nihilism at work.

Dzilna’s pretty good on this, admitting straight away that the film could be taken as a

“slick Hollywood story about a guy who is tired of his 9 to 5 job and life revolving around Ikea catalogs, so he blows up his apartment, starts a fist-fighting club, moves on to become a terrorist mastermind … and gets the girl in the end”.

But Dzilna concerntrates on the possiblity that there’s something more going on (though you probably have to choose to see it). Here’s the abstract from Fight Club: Violence as Yoga.

Ed NortonThis essay is an interpretation of the movie Fight Club as a Zen Buddhist allegory, specifically, a search for identity in a world of consumerism and abstraction. By defining himself with the illusions of a consumerist lifestyle—foisted on today’s modern society by an advertising machine that perpetually imposes unattainable desires—the protagonist Jack feels frustrated because he can never achieve those illusions of identity. He uses fighting and terrorism as his yoga to destroy the abstractions of maya, or illusion, that identify him.

Jack, played by the always good Ed Norton, goes to meetings. Dzilna captures something of the radical emotional surgery of the 12-step programmes …

Initially, the meetings help. Jack is able to sleep soundly and has feelings of liberation: “I found freedom. Losing all hope was freedom.” Participants are told to really open ourselves up,” which is to say, become open to who you are, and let go of the abstract standards and conventional thinking about whom you are supposed to be.

… but:

marlaBut Jack isn’t really liberated. He is identifying himself with another representation, this time a “poor, sick little me” that gets recognition because of a lie that he has testicular cancer, AIDS or tuberculosis. He only pretends to be the identity of Rupert, Cornelius or “whatever name he gives himself each night,” as Marla points out. The liberation Jack experiences, when “every evening I died and every evening I was born again, resurrected,” is just a vacation from samsara. He is a tourist who is “addicted” and “needs this.” Jack also starts desiring Marla, whose chicanery of identity—by attending the testicular cancer group, she even feigns gender—reflects Jack’s.


One thought on “Tyler Durden in an orange robe

  1. andres says:

    Some reflexions about tyler`s mood and attitude.

    Trying to find himself¿? Could be agree. He virtually and essenltialy “looses his 21th century mask, armor and online profile”. He experienced(not suffered, that was the phrase i inmediately thought) some kind of desprogramation of the values of the posmodern society, values that are ruled by beauty, money and bla-bla bullshit!. This de-programation is not passive, noenetheless its through pain and its catarquic properties, those properties who give a wisdom look, safe appearence and absolutely no fear to the person who suffers that pain. But the real deal is that is not an involuntaey pain, is a pain 100% voluntary and desireable. thats why i think tyler durden is a semi-good(demi-dieu), because he chooses pain, and he knows is the gate to another dimension of selfactualization and selfpotentiation of infinite capacities.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

August 2007
    Nov »
%d bloggers like this: